Philip’s practice covers all areas of property litigation including commercial and residential landlord and tenant matters and real property disputes. He has extensive experience of proceedings in the County Courts, the High Court and the Court of Appeal as well as regularly appearing in the Property Chamber of both the First Tier and Upper Tribunals. Philip also regularly represents clients at mediations and in arbitrations.
Philip’s recent cases have included the following areas:
- Residential landlord and tenant disputes, including enfranchisement, right to manage, service charges and possession proceedings
- Mortgage disputes ranging from straightforward possession claims to more complex cases involving fraud and undue influence and land registration issues
- Easements, restrictive covenants and boundary disputes
- Commercial landlord and tenant disputes including renewal proceedings under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954, dilapidations claims and forfeiture proceedings
- Development agreements, including options, conditional agreements for sale and related planning and valuation issues
- Insolvency matters with a significant property element, including disclaimer, vesting orders and escheat.
- 2000 - 2003, St Catherine's College, Oxford - B.A. Jurisprudence (1st class)
- 2003 - 2004, St Catherine's College, Oxford - B.C.L.
- 2004 - 2005, Inns of Court School of Law, Bar Vocational Course (Very Competent)
- Called, Inner Temple 2005 - BVC Major Scholarship.
- Father’s Field Developments Ltd v Namulas Pension Trustees Ltd  UKUT (Lands Tribunal) – Successful application for discharge of restrictive covenant pursuant to s. 84 (1) of the Law of Property Act; ability to extract a ransom not a practical benefit to objector. Costs in favour of the applicant on basis of objector’s unreasonable conduct
- Omya UK Ltd v Andrews Excavations Ltd  8 WLUK 111 – circumstances in which it is appropriate to permit party to increase their cost budget; unexpected volume of third-party disclosure was a significant development justifying increase.
- Smoke Club Ltd (In Administration v Network Rail Infrastructure Ltd  UKUT 78 (Lands Tribunal – acting for Network Rail in relation to claim for compensation for compulsory acquisition of night club premises as part of Thameslink Project; claim for long lease by virtue of proprietary estoppel unsuccessful; occupation and payment of rent gave rise to annual periodic tenancy, not tenancy at will.
- Criterion Buildings Ltd v McKinsey  2 P& CR DG4 (with Stephen Jourdan Q.C.) – commercial service charges; fairness of landlord’s apportionment of costs, operation of reserve/sinking fund.
- Caledonian Management Services Ltd v Clivedale Properties Ltd  EWHC 2974 (Comm) – whether purchaser of new build flat was entitled to rescind contract for sale on basis of non-compliance with conditions prior to long-stop date; conclusiveness of certificate of compliance with building regulations.
- Stanning v Baldwin  EWHC 1350 (Ch) – Entitlement to rely on easement by prescription (over a common) to access new development, establishing prescriptive easement of drainage, correct approach to position of boundary.
- Solid Rock Investments (UK) Ltd v Reddy and others  EWHC 3043, Henry Carr J -
claim to recover a deposit paid upon entering a contract for sale of development property pursuant to s. 49 (2) of the Law of Property Act 1925.
- Loose v Lynn Shellfish Ltd & Ors,  2 W.L.R. 1126, Supreme Court (with Guy Fetherstonhaugh Q.C. and Charles Harpum) - important case concerning the seaward extent of a private fishery and the proper approach to the construction of a presumed grant established by virtue of prescription; impact of a grant of a movable boundary and the law of accretion on the extent of fisheries and other proprietary rights in coastal waters.
- Christopher Moran Holdings Limited v Carrarra-Cagni  UKUT 152 – obligation of residential tenants to contribute to cost of repairs to later additions to building.
- Sainsbury’s Supermarkets Limited v Bristol Rovers (188) Limited  1 P. & C.R. 6 (High Court)  EWCA Civ 160 (Court of Appeal) (with Mark Wonnacott Q.C.) - conditional agreement for the sale and purchase of Bristol Rovers’ football stadium, the Memorial Ground; entitlement of Sainsbury’s to terminate based on no compliance with conditions.
- Page v Convoy Investments Ltd  EWCA Civ 1061 (Court of Appeal) – scope of right of way in favour of agricultural land; did gates amount to substantial interference/
- Assethold Limited v Watts  L. & T.R. 15, Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber) – whether legal fees incurred by landlord properly recoverable as part of residential service charge.
- Innerspaces Self Storage Ltd v Harding & Ors  EWCA Civ 46 (Court of Appeal) -
proper construction of service charge provision in commercial lease.
- Quadracolor Ltd v Crown Estate Commissioners  EWHC 4842 – escheat of freehold interest to the Crown. Grant of a vesting order in favour of the Claimant pursuant to s. 181 of the Law of Property Act 1925.
- Money back guarantee? Costs recovery under long residential leases and costs orders in the First Tier Tribunal. Part1: New Law Journal. 2016, 166(7718), 13-15, Part 2 New Law Journal 2016, 166 (7719), 13
- Forfeiture revisited: Magnic, Safin and Freifeld The Conveyancer and Property Lawyer. 2016, 4, 317-326
- The final curtain? McDonald v McDonald, Landlord and Tenant and Human Rights; New Law Journal 164 (7621), 11-12
- Is talk cheap? After Daejan Investments Ltd v Benson can landlords buy themselves out of consulting with tenants under s.20 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985 and what should be the price of doing so? Conveyancer and Property Lawyer Conv. (2014) No.2 Pages 156-164
- The right to manage and appurtenant property: Gala Unity Ltd v Ariadne Road RTM Co Ltd, Conveyancer and Property Lawyer Conv. (2013) No.5 Pages 447-454
- Putting on the breaks; the effect of the decision in Marks & Spencer Plc v BNP Paribas Securities Services Trust Co (Jersey) Ltd, New Law Journal N.L.J. (2013) Vol.163 No.7571 Pages 15-17
- Commercial and Residential Service Charges, Butterworths, 2013; Co-author
- Woodfall: Landlord and Tenant Bulletin, Contributing Editor.